It was gift giving with the best intentions, and all that. Only a bit self-serving, but in the end it caught up with me as these things often do.
For the last year or so my 14-year old anime-infatuated daughter has enjoyed viewing her portfolio of shows streamed online using her MacBook or via the impressively capable Roku box attached to her HDTV. All was well and good, but Dad of course can't leave well enough alone. No, a bit before Christmas I came up with the grand plan to move the Roku box back to the aging, mostly-analog IDTV in our living room and instead "upgrade" my daughter's setup to something better.
Win-win, right? The Roku with its S-video and digitial-audio outputs will work fine with my turn-of-the-century living room systems, and daughter gets upgraded to state-of-the-art (again) in her room.
So the holiday arrives, presents are opened, etc. Dad goes and installs an AppleTV on daughter's system when she's out of the house, to surprise her when she returns.
Uh yeah. It was a surprise alright.
Not because the ATV is anything other than a quality system. The hardware, software and out-of-box-experience is typical Apple, which is to say that it's almost flawless. Everything plugs and plays without a hitch, from the HDMI video and audio, to the 802.11n wireless, to the iTunes integration. The hardware quality make me want to put it on a pedestal with a tiny spotlight illuminating its flawless finish. No power brick is an unexpected bonus. As always, the Apple UI/UX is simple and elegant (except for the infuriating need to enter characters using the same limited hunt and peck interface as almost all other STBs.) And, I'm enthralled with the way it integrates audio and video podcasts along with other OTT content.
Which brings me to the surprise that with a little more research shouldn't have been a surprise to me. When my daughter gets home and fires up the ATV, her initial delight turns to abject horror when she realizes a) her favorite anime content is limited to one or two episodes/seasons of each title, and b) HORROR OF HORRORS EACH EPISODE COSTS $0.99 TO RENT.
Yep, on the Roku via Crunchyroll it's all free, all seasons, all episodes, all the time. Squid Girl, Inuyasha, Naruto, Yumeiro Patisserie, etc. Every repetitive conflict, every demonic possession, every heartbreaking love triangle.
So, I say "Okay, with iOS 4.2 and AirPlay we can just watch her favorite shows for free on her MacBook or iPhone and then stream the content to the ATV, right?"
Wrong.
For now, AirPlay only works with "Apple-approved" content like that available in iTunes or YouTube. The ever-innovative
Erica Sadun has an impressive work-in-progress called
AirFlick that promises to wriggle around Apple's onerous restrictions, but it's still in a too-geeky state to be usable by the masses. After two hours of futzing, I threw in the towel. The Roku box is back on my daughter's TV. The AppleTV is back in its box ready to be returned on Monday.
Observations and lessons learned (again):
1. Don't mess with what's working for your daughter unless you're really sure it's gonna be an improvement.
2. Roku continues to lead the OTT marketplace with the richest set of content choices, at prices and a user experience that continues to build brand and customer loyalty. Added bonus points for Roku's support for analog video; not all of us can afford digital TVs throughout the house.
3. I seriously considered getting her a Boxee box instead of the ATV, but they're still lacking Netflix streaming support -- a must IMHO.
4. As Chairman Steve says, ATV may still be more of a hobby than a complete product, thought it's a really cool hobby. When AirPlay becomes source- and content-agnostic it will be a lot closer to delivering the vision promoted in Apple's advertising.
It's the first time I've ever had to de-install and return an Apple product. Statistically, I guess it was bound to happen someday. For now, I'll continue to be an enthusiastic Roku evangelist while waiting for AppleTV to evolve to be a more mature solution. And in 2011 I resolve to try harder to avoid giving self-serving presents to others!
Postscript 01/03/11 - Good to know that the return process at my local Apple store was as painless as the online purchase. Walk in the front door, tell the greeter that I want to return an item for credit, get assigned an Apple associate, give them the ATV and HDMI cable and printed copy of online receipt, and all is taken care of for me. Of course there's a 10% open-box restocking fee, but that was expected.